Spoiler! Is Roxas Ven's nobody?

I say this thread on another KH website and I wanted to see what you guys have got to say about it. Oh and here is a quote from the guy who originally started it

I don't get how this is possible.

How can Roxas be Sora's nobody? Axel's former self wasn't another person. Lea IS Axel.... right? Along with every other ORG member.

But Roxas coexisted with Sora. And doesn't even look like Sora. He looks like Ven's nobody, and even acts a little like him, AND sounds like him.

And IT MAKES SENSE. Ven lost his heart and gave it to Sora. Ven is a lifeless body in Castle Oblivion.

.....

and here is the link to the thread Spoiler! Is Riku Ven's nobody? and the reason this threads name is different is because he was talking about Roxas not Riku.

ermm you have a point there. let me say what i think happens in my opinion. I just think that roxas is kinda a nobody of ven and sora. since ven gave his heart to sora, some of sora's heart were hidden and probaly unlocked and made a nobody looking ven. but some of the organization probaly might night remember and called roxas roxas(i said roxas x2 cuz it just is) cause of sora's name. but some of them like xigbar probaly remmebered like at xion when he saw her like ven.

Square enix have to be planning something, why else make the new character exactly. the. same. as roxas and/or sora? :S